Tito Bandito's Menu

Tito Bandito’s in Pine Hill, NY, delivers an inspired take on Mexican cuisine with a fresh, upscale twist. The menu shines with vibrant staples such as shrimp and chicken tacos, each bursting with bold, authentic flavors. Their specialty margaritas, like the Pineapple Jalapeño and Hibiscus versions, elevate the experience with a perfect blend of zest and sweetness. Noteworthy dishes like the quesadillas and the “Tacos Amazingness” showcase creative, satisfying combinations, while the sides—rice, beans, and creamy guacamole—complement beautifully. Don’t miss the indulgent spice tres leches cake and Mexican chocolate brownie, which offer a memorable finish. The drink selection, featuring an impressive range of mezcal and reposado tequilas, caters to both casual drinkers and aficionados. Guests consistently praise the attentive service and seasonal specials, such as the Elderberry & Pear margarita or braised short rib tacos with peach salsa, highlighting the kitchen’s commitment to fresh, local ingredients. Tito Bandito’s is a flavorful escape where tradition meets innovation in every bite and sip.